Hold on to Your Seniors


TL;DR

  • SURVEY CLOSING: The State of Digital Services 2026 survey closes Monday, 3/9. Be sure to participate before then to get access to the full report and live readout webinar.
  • Agencies have largely stopped hiring entry-level and junior talent since 2022-23. That gap will show up later as a shortage of mid-level and senior practitioners.
  • At the same time, AI is absorbing the kind of repetitive production work juniors used to do across coding, marketing, and design.
  • Senior talent remains essential because the hardest parts of the work are architecture, strategy, integration, risk management, and deciding what should actually be built or shipped.
  • The result is a structural shift: smaller teams of senior operators directing AI-assisted production instead of large pyramids of junior execution.
  • If the junior pipeline stays weak, senior practitioners could become one of the scarcest and most valuable resources in the agency economy in the coming years.

Hold on to Your Seniors

Senior coders, marketers, and designers, that is.

The industry as a whole has essentially stopped hiring entry-level and junior-level talent for a few years, which could make senior-level talent incredibly valuable in the coming years.

For the sake of argument, we're going to assume that LLMs continue to become more capable over the next 5 years.

But even if they don't, there's still going to be a major hole in the market where 2023's entry-level hires should have become 2028's mid-level talent.

Let's explore how this is playing out across the three core agency disciplines: software, marketing, and design.

AI's Already Eating Software

Writing code is one step in a longer chain. Architecture decisions, system integration, testing, and deployment often determine the success or failure of a project.

The importance of "non-code writing activities" becomes clear when we look at engineering benchmarks.

Tools like SWE-bench evaluate whether systems can resolve real GitHub issues, which typically require coordinated changes across multiple files that must pass a full test suite.

Today's top models are solving three-quarters of these issues.

On the other hand, you have security and reliability. A 2025 analysis by Veracode, which tested more than 100 large language models across 80 coding tasks, found that AI-generated code introduced known security vulnerabilities in 45% of cases.

Many of those aren't the things entry-level talent will notice, but senior-level talent will flag them immediately.

So you have a situation where AI can solve the simple stuff that early-stage talent would normally work on, but it has trouble with senior-level tasks, and at the same time, the talent pipeline has been severely disrupted.

We'll still get some new seniors from the mid-level talent that's still in the pipeline,

Next, There's Marketing

If we map what's happening in the software space to marketing activities, we see a similar, but less pronounced pattern.

It's been most evident in the content space, but it's seeping into ads, conversion-rate-optimization, SEO/GEO, and more.

Google’s own Ads roadmap describes campaign creation flows where the system can summarize a landing page and generate keywords, headlines, descriptions, and images, with humans editing and shipping.

And there are already examples from agencies of cost and delivery-time compression in our surveys.

Finally, Design

Design, specifically web design, is in a weird spot, and I still blame Bootstrap for it.

Almost every company that purchased design services wasn't buying art. They were buying attention or conversions. And this sucks when you conflate design with art because the market has forced an optimization of design. This is why everything from websites to phones to cars looks the same now.

It's lame. I don't like it. But from a "growing an agency"-perspective, there are fascinating advances in churning out tons of highly effective design assets.

I'd expect the seniors in this space to follow their coding and marketing counterparts to become something more like a conductor, if they haven't already.

What This Means for Agencies

We've been seeing agencies trend toward strategy (vs. execution) for years now. Five years ago, the argument was better pricing power. Now that argument's changed to relevance.

For those that have made the shift, there's a lot of opportunity here with AI being more painful for your more execution-focused competitors.

As execution becomes commoditized, the strategy and process for determining what to make will be even more valuable.

The people who enable that are the senior practitioners.

We're already seeing evidence of shops reconfiguring themselves around a smaller team of experts, supported by contractors and AI. That may be the model going forward, but it's still too early to tell, especially with how uneven AI's capabilities are across the various agency disciplines.

Hope this helps you better navigate these changes as they're happening quickly.

Until next time!

Research & Strategy for Digital Agencies

The latest research, insights, tools, and resources that make managing a digital shop easier,

Read more from Research & Strategy for Digital Agencies

TL;DR We launched a new Digital Agency Growth Guide The widening gap between thriving and struggling digital agencies traces back to a misunderstanding of revenue generation. A large portion of the industry borrowed SaaS and product go-to-market tactics that don't fit how they win clients, and many misapplied generic best practices. There's no universal "best practice." Tactics succeed when they fit your agency's operating style and fail when they conflict with it. The 78-page Growth Guide is...

TL;DR Welcome to the new-look newsletter! We're launching a new Digital Agency Growth Guide. Delphi members will get it early. Join Delphi so you get the guide as soon as it drops. Value-Based Pricing was supposed to save us, but usage fell from 31% of agencies in 2024 to 18% in 2025 Agencies still using it grew more slowly than every other pricing model in the survey AI exposed how much of the "value" was actually still execution, and clients caught on Most agencies pitching VBP can't...

TL;DR We're enhancing Delphi membership with discounts on our Digital Agency Growth Review. We tested 29 variables across eight years of our State of Digital Services data to find what consistently separates Fast-tier growers from the rest. Five factors provided durable positive impacts on agency growth. Bigger engagements — the most stable signal in the analysis. Bigger clients Service specialization (by service mix, not by industry alone) Raised hourly rates Service mix evolution — the...