Buying Digital Agencies Can Destroy Value


Notes from Nick

A recap of the key topics that have come up recently in chats with agency owners.

M&A activity has been red hot for over a year now, but it’s coming up in almost every new client call these days. Some are seeing multiple inquiries a month for their agencies, while others are asking for help with acquisition strategies of their own. Acquisitions are a tool but for whatever reason, they’re seen as the coolest tool in the box. They give off this air of “I’m doing real business!” but if you aren’t careful, they can destroy value.

There are some general strategies when it comes to acquisitions: buy and improve, industry consolidation, economies of scale, buying R&D, etc. Here’s a quick overview of the two most common archetypes used in the digital services space and how we’ve seen them play out.

Buying clients

The average digital shop tends to grow around 15% per year (last year was an anomaly at 25%!). That rate isn’t super attractive to some owners, and they decide they can grow more quickly by purchasing and integrating another agency.

Purchasing is the easy part. A lot of the really difficult valuation work goes out the window when capital is almost free.

Integration is where the pain begins. None of the integration work is easy. Brand strategies, remotely combining cultures, overlap removal, system integration, and training for the new employees, all drain leadership’s time and focus.

That’s true for any strategy though; what’s unique here is the growth goal. This goal pushes the acquirer to take the biggest bite they can, often resulting in an acquisition of a shop only slightly smaller than themselves.

Yes, the company doubled but first-year margins will most definitely take a hit. Integration work requires resources after all. On top of reduced margins, we’re left wondering where future growth comes from. They still have the same sales and marketing teams with presumably lower investment over the last year which results in sub-average growth rates. Then, the average client only sticks around for a few years, so the clients they bought are starting to leave. This client attrition is exacerbated by brand integrations.

This results in a one-time growth boost that’s typically less than advertised while margins get punched in the gut and you grow a bit slower going forward. Not a great recipe for increasing enterprise value.

Caveat: There are shops that can get good at the integration work that can make this strategy successful but they tend to have incredibly solid supporting functions (finance, operations, sales and marketing, human resources). They also have limits on the size and frequency they’ll integrate.

So what’s an example of an acquisition strategy that works?

Buying a niche

Expanding or deepening your expertise in a specific niche via small tuck-in acquisitions can be a great way to build a shop. Since these are larger shops buying significantly smaller shops, much of the integration work is simpler. Adding 10 new FTEs for a 70-person shop is orders of magnitude simpler than a merger of equals.

Since it’s a tuck-in, the brand work and system integrations are essentially eliminated. The only real thing to do is prep your sales and marketing campaigns to include the new services/industries.

Overlap removal is also less of an issue since most small shops outsource their support services (legal and accounting) or it’s done by the owner.

This leaves the people side of the equation. Training and culture integration can still throw a wrench into things, but again, the size difference tends to help here.

This results in a significantly lower drain on resources for the acquirer. That leaves more resources to devote to growing the new niche which lessens the impact on margins and future growth from client turnover.

This strategy nets out to above industry average top-line growth, minimal margin impact, and plenty of resources to devote to growing the newly acquired niche.

The bottom line

Our advice in this area can be boiled down to this: Buy with purpose. We don’t hate acquisitions but they can easily become a distraction from true value creation.


Researched Resources

A curated list of recent articles from around the web and some thoughts on their topic's impact for your industry.


Pro(methean) Tip

Some of our most commonly given advice to make managing a digital shop just a bit easier.

Relentless focus on being great in a few core areas allows agencies to grow more reliably than spreading focus too broadly. Avoiding shiny focus traps can be difficult but the long-term rewards are worth it. Acquisitions can pretty easily fall into the category of "shiny focus trap."

Research & Strategy for Digital Agencies

The latest research, insights, tools, and resources that make managing a digital shop easier,

Read more from Research & Strategy for Digital Agencies

TL;DR Many agencies are in planning mode this time of year. To support them, we launched a new research piece on standardized job descriptions and an entirely new level of Delphi that brings our salary and positioning research directly into the AI tools leadership teams already use. Meet Delphi Oracle Delphi members already get quarterly updates on agency sales pipelines, hiring plans, service and industry demand, and trends impacting agency sales. Now, we're adding deep dives into how 23k...

TL;DR We analyzed 3,184 job postings from 820 U.S. digital agencies. You can find our full writeups at: Digital Agency Salary Benchmarks & Digital Agency Hiring Trends. We're considering doing this regularly for our Delphi group. Join now so you don't miss it. Advertised pay for account managers is now 10% higher than what agencies paid two years ago and 22% higher for Account Directors. Today's junior hires will grow into tomorrow's mid-level employees in about three years. Agencies...

TL;DR Last year, we built Delphi - an insights network for agency leaders. Now hundreds of them get quarterly updates that keep them informed about key industry shifts. We're expanding this network and opening a dedicated sponsor slot for 2027. We've already had multiple firms reach out, so we'll be selecting the sponsor in the next few weeks. Reply if you'd like to explore sponsoring the Delphi network. We analyzed over 1k job postings from a few hundred digital agencies and built average...